The Blood and Wine expansion for The Witcher 3 introduces numerous memorable side quests across the vibrant region of Toussaint. Among these, Father Knows Worst stands out as a humorous yet tense family drama involving three brothers arguing over a inherited distillery. Players must navigate sibling rivalry and monster threats to secure the best possible resolution for everyone involved.
Starting the Quest and Locating Hermit Cave
Geralt initiates the quest after picking up a contract at the Gran'place notice board or speaking directly to Hugo inside the Clever Clogs Inn. Hugo reveals that his brothers have locked him out of their late father's estate and distillery operations. Track the quest marker to the cave where Hugo is trapped and eliminate the aggressive monsters guarding the entrance.
Navigating the Confrontation Between the Brothers
Once Hugo is freed from the cave, he asks Geralt to accompany him to meet his brothers, Vitalis and Louis. Upon arrival at the meeting point, an intense argument breaks out regarding the division of their father's legacy. Geralt must make a critical dialogue choice here that determines whether the situation devolves into violence or ends peacefully.
Securing the Best Outcome for the Family
To achieve the best outcome, choose the dialogue option that encourages the brothers to reconcile rather than fight. Diffusing the tension allows the trio to reach an agreement and successfully reopen their father's wine business together. Choosing peace rewards Geralt with crowns and unlocks special discounts at their newly established shop later in Toussaint.
Alternative Choices and Their Consequences
If Geralt chooses to side aggressively with Hugo or permits the argument to escalate, a duel will break out between the siblings. Escalating the conflict leads to the death of Vitalis and Louis, leaving Hugo consumed by guilt over the tragic outcome. While Geralt still receives his monetary reward, this violent path permanently locks out the family business and its associated vendor benefits.
